A late start in Gettysburg
Eddie Plank grew up on a Pennsylvania farm and began playing organized baseball when a neighbor put a team together. His connection to Gettysburg College baseball brought him to the attention of professional scouts. Connie Mack took him directly into the Athletics' rotation. [1]
Making the hitter wait
Plank developed a deliberate routine between pitches, adjusting his clothing and inspecting the ball before delivering it. The left-hander kept opponents waiting and seldom offered a comfortable at-bat. He became a mainstay of Philadelphia's early championships and later pitched in the Federal League. [1]
The cost of a single run
Plank and Chief Bender made time for rookie teammates. Plank's family remembered him as someone who said little but expected people to listen when he did speak. He invested his earnings carefully and remained rooted in Gettysburg, where his later work included farming and guiding visitors around the battlefield. [1] [2]
Back to the battlefield town
Plank returned to Gettysburg with his wife Anna and their son. He operated a Buick business and took visitors around the Civil War battlefield. When the Yankees acquired his rights late in his career, he chose retirement over another season away from home. [1]
Gettysburg remained part of his life
Plank’s nickname, “Gettysburg Eddie,” reflected more than his birthplace. During the off-season, he worked as a guide at Gettysburg National Military Park and sometimes took teammates on tours of the battlefield. After his playing days, he stayed in the town and remained part of its local life. [3]
Two games on the record
May 13, 1901 — Oriole Park III: Philadelphia Athletics lost 5–14 to Baltimore Orioles. Eddie Plank pitched 2 innings, allowing three hits and three runs, all earned; walked two batters and struck out one batter. At bat, he went 0-for-1.
August 6, 1917 — Griffith Stadium: St. Louis Browns lost 0–1 to Washington Senators. Eddie Plank pitched 10⅓ innings, allowing five hits and one run, all earned; walked three batters and struck out three batters. At bat, he went 0-for-2 and drew a walk. [4] [5]
He chose his Gettysburg home over one last major-league season
At 41, Plank’s final major-league appearance was an 11-inning loss to Walter Johnson on August 6, 1917. Stomach trouble helped end his career, but his decision to stay retired was also a choice about the life he had built at home. The Yankees acquired his rights that winter, which could have returned him to the majors at age 42. From his Gettysburg farm, he said he was finished with baseball and had “my farm and my home and enough to take care of me.” He briefly pitched in a nearby industrial league, keeping the game close without leaving his community. [6]
Teams and seasons on record
Each year opens the roster and standings for that club.
- Philadelphia Athletics · 1901, 1902, 1903, 1904, 1905, 1906, 1907, 1908, 1909, 1910, 1911, 1912, 1913, 1914
- St. Louis Terriers · 1915
- St. Louis Browns · 1916, 1917
Teammate biographies
- Eddie Collins · 1906 Philadelphia Athletics
- Rube Waddell · 1902 Philadelphia Athletics
- George Sisler · 1916 St. Louis Browns
Biographical sources
- Eddie Plank, SABR BioProject
- Eddie Plank, National Baseball Hall of Fame
- mlb.com · c 105917880
- Baltimore Orioles 14, Philadelphia Athletics 5 at Oriole Park III, May 13, 1901 · Retrosheet box score
- Washington Senators 1, St. Louis Browns 0 at Griffith Stadium, August 6, 1917 · Retrosheet box score
- Eddie Plank, SABR BioProject
Biography reviewed 2026-11-17. Suggest a correction with a source.