The “Iron Man” spent his offseasons in a foundry
When a reporter asked about the work, McGinnity called himself an “iron man.” The name later seemed an even better fit for his extraordinary workload as a pitcher. [1]
After organized play, McGinnity stayed in baseball as a pitching coach for the Brooklyn Dodgers. Even then he questioned the expanding use of large pitching staffs, arguing that teams needed only a handful of pitchers. His later coaching reflected the same practical, workmanlike view of pitching that shaped his playing reputation. [1] [2]
New York Giants in 1904
McGinnity made 44 starts for the 1904 New York Giants, working 408 innings. His record was 35–8 with 144 strikeouts. He was credited with 38 complete games. In the 1905 World Series, McGinnity pitched 17 innings for the New York Giants. He entered the Hall of Fame with the class of 1946 as a player. [3] [4] [2]
At the plate against the New York Giants
On April 18, 1899, Joe McGinnity went 2-for-3 against the New York Giants. The Baltimore Orioles beat the New York Giants 8–4. [5] [6]
World Series against the Philadelphia Athletics
Joe McGinnity pitched 9 innings for the New York Giants against the Philadelphia Athletics on October 13, 1905, in the 1905 World Series. He struck out four and held the opposition to five hits. None of the hits led to an earned run against him. The New York Giants won 1–0. [7] [8]
New York Giants teammates in 1905
McGinnity led the 1905 New York Giants in starts with 38. Christy Mathewson was the nearest teammate with 37. His 46 appearances included 38 starts and 8 games in relief. The New York Giants finished 105–48 and won the World Series. [4] [3] [9]
Teams and seasons on record
Each year opens the roster and standings for that club.
- Baltimore Orioles · 1899, 1901, 1902
- Brooklyn Superbas · 1900
- New York Giants · 1902, 1903, 1904, 1905, 1906, 1907, 1908
Teammate biographies
- John McGraw · 1899 Baltimore Orioles
- Roger Bresnahan · 1901 Baltimore Orioles
- Christy Mathewson · 1902 New York Giants
Biographical sources
- Joe McGinnity · SABR BioProject
- Joe McGinnity · National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum
- Joe McGinnity · Retrosheet
- Lahman Baseball Database – Society for American Baseball Research
- Baltimore Orioles 8, New York Giants 4 · Retrosheet box score
- Top Performances for Joe McGinnity · Retrosheet game records
- New York Giants 1, Philadelphia Athletics 0 · Retrosheet box score
- The 1905 NY N World Series Pitching Log for Joe McGinnity · Retrosheet
- The 1905 New York Giants · Retrosheet
Biography reviewed 2026-11-18. Suggest a correction with a source.