An injured hand in Indiana
Mordecai Brown grew up in the farming community of Nyesville, Indiana. A childhood machinery accident and a later injury permanently altered his pitching hand. The grip he developed with those fingers gave his pitches unusual movement. He earned a living in the mines before baseball supported him. [1]
Pitching for the Cubs
Brown reached the majors with St. Louis and moved to Chicago after his rookie year. He became one of the leading pitchers on the Cubs teams that won consecutive championships in 1907 and 1908. His matchups with Christy Mathewson put two very different deliveries on display. [1]
From Nyesville to the Chicago rotation
Brown married Sarah Burgham in Rosedale, Indiana, in December 1903, before his move to Chicago. They had no children and remained married for 45 years. Teammate Johnny Evers remembered his readiness to pitch and friendliness to opponents. Brown also became known for his rivalry with Christy Mathewson and for the championship Cubs teams on which he pitched. [1] [2]
Terre Haute
After playing and managing, Brown operated a service station in Terre Haute. Decades later, relatives helped erect a marker in Nyesville, where his life had begun. [1]
The hand injury became part of his delivery
Brown injured his right hand twice as a child on his family farm: a feed chopper severed most of his index finger, and a later fall broke bones while the hand was healing. His altered grip helped create unusual spin. On October 12, 1907, he used that hand to shut out Detroit on two hits and clinch the Cubs’ first World Series title. [3]
Two games on the record
April 19, 1903 — Robison Field: St. Louis Cardinals beat Chicago Cubs, 3–0. Mordecai Brown pitched 5 innings, allowing one hit and no runs; walked two batters and struck out no batters. At bat, he went 0-for-2 and struck out two times.
September 4, 1916 — Weeghman Park: Chicago Cubs lost 8–10 to Cincinnati Reds. Mordecai Brown pitched 9 innings, allowing 19 hits and ten runs, including nine earned runs; walked once and struck out two batters. At bat, he went 2-for-4 and scored twice. [4] [5]
His final major-league game reunited him with Mathewson
Brown’s last major-league appearance came on Labor Day 1916, in a heavily promoted matchup against Christy Mathewson, then player-manager of Cincinnati. Mathewson won, and the game proved to be the final big-league performance for both rivals. Brown continued pitching in the minors afterward, but the ending gave a natural close to a rivalry that had followed him from his early seasons with Chicago. He finished their major-league meetings with 12 wins, 11 losses and one no-decision, so the last game tipped the single contest to Mathewson without changing the closely matched career record between them. [1]
Teams and seasons on record
Each year opens the roster and standings for that club.
- St. Louis Cardinals · 1903
- Chicago Cubs · 1904, 1905, 1906, 1907, 1908, 1909, 1910, 1911, 1912, 1916
- Cincinnati Reds · 1913
- Brooklyn Tip-Tops · 1914
- St. Louis Terriers · 1914
- Chicago Whales · 1915
Biographical sources
- Mordecai Brown, SABR BioProject
- Mordecai Brown, National Baseball Hall of Fame
- mlb.com · c 154046904
- St. Louis Cardinals 3, Chicago Cubs 0 at Robison Field, April 19, 1903 · Retrosheet box score
- Cincinnati Reds 10, Chicago Cubs 8 at Weeghman Park, September 4, 1916 · Retrosheet box score
Biography reviewed 2026-11-17. Suggest a correction with a source.