A Chicago family of deaf parents raised a future umpire and manager
Hank O’Day was born in Chicago, the middle child of seven in a family headed by Irish immigrants. His parents were deaf. His father worked in several trades, including operating a small farm, plumbing, and engineering at a school. O’Day’s baseball career would later cross roles as player, manager, and umpire. [3]
O’Day became one of the game’s best-known umpires, working World Series games and helping drive rule changes. The details of his family background are less widely told than his work on the field, but they place his career in a large immigrant household in nineteenth-century Chicago. [3] [4]
Who made the call on Fred Merkle?
As a pitcher, O'Day helped the 1889 Giants beat Brooklyn in the postseason. As an umpire he worked the first modern World Series in 1903. In September 1908 he was behind the plate when Al Bridwell singled with two outs, a runner crossed home and Fred Merkle failed to touch second. Johnny Evers claimed the force out for Chicago. O'Day's ruling erased the run and made a previously routine departure from the field one of baseball's most closely examined baserunning decisions. [4]
Washington Nationals in 1888
O'Day made 46 starts for the 1888 Washington Nationals, working 403 innings. His record was 16–29 with 186 strikeouts. He was credited with 46 complete games. In the 1889 World Series, O'Day pitched 23 innings for the New York Giants. He entered the Hall of Fame with the class of 2013 as an umpire. [1] [2] [4]
New York Giants teammates in 1890
O'Day led the 1890 New York Giants in wins with 22. John Ewing was the nearest teammate with 18. His 43 appearances included 35 starts and 8 games in relief. The New York Giants finished 74–57. [2] [1] [5]
Teams and seasons on record
Each year opens the roster and standings for that club.
- Toledo Blue Stockings · 1884
- Pittsburg Alleghenys · 1885
- Washington Nationals · 1886, 1887, 1888, 1889
- New York Giants · 1889, 1890
Teammate biographies
- Connie Mack · 1886 Washington Nationals
- Buck Ewing · 1889 New York Giants
- Jim O'Rourke · 1889 New York Giants
Biographical sources
- Hank O'Day · Retrosheet
- Lahman Baseball Database – Society for American Baseball Research
- Hank O’Day · SABR BioProject
- Hank O'Day · National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum
- The 1890 New York Giants (P) · Retrosheet
Biography reviewed 2026-11-18. Suggest a correction with a source.