A shortstop with an eye for practical jokes
He once crept up behind Texas pitcher Gaylord Perry and sprinkled itching powder on him. Harrah’s career supplied plenty of legitimate baseball curiosities, too, including an unusual doubleheader in which the shortstop was never credited with a fielding chance. [1]
The joke and the scorekeeping oddity could easily overshadow how steadily useful he was. Texas eventually inducted Harrah into its franchise Hall of Fame in 2009. He had helped connect the Senators’ final Washington years to the beginning of major-league baseball in Arlington. [1]
His first game for the Washington Senators
The Philadelphia Phillies signed Harrah as an amateur free agent in 1966. Toby Harrah played his first game for the Washington Senators on September 5, 1969, against the Boston Red Sox. He pinch-ran for Ken McMullen. He did not have an official at-bat. [2] [3]
Cleveland Indians in 1982
Harrah batted .304 for the 1982 Cleveland Indians, collecting 183 hits in 602 at-bats. He hit 25 home runs and drove in 78 runs. [2] [4]
How Harrah reached the Cleveland Indians
On December 8, 1978, the Cleveland Indians acquired Harrah from the Texas Rangers in exchange for Buddy Bell. [2]
Five hits against the Toronto Blue Jays
On July 31, 1983, Toby Harrah went 5-for-5 against the Toronto Blue Jays. Harrah drove in three of the 16 runs his club scored. The Cleveland Indians beat the Toronto Blue Jays 16–11. [5] [6]
Texas Rangers teammates in 1977
Harrah led the 1977 Texas Rangers in home runs with 27. Mike Hargrove was the nearest teammate with 18. The Texas Rangers finished 94–68. [4] [2] [7]
Teams and seasons on record
Each year opens the roster and standings for that club.
- Washington Senators · 1969, 1971
- Texas Rangers · 1972, 1973, 1974, 1975, 1976, 1977, 1978, 1985, 1986
- Cleveland Indians · 1979, 1980, 1981, 1982, 1983
- New York Yankees · 1984
Teammate biographies
- Mike Hargrove · 1974 Texas Rangers
- Jeff Burroughs · 1971 Washington Senators
- Bert Blyleven · 1976 Texas Rangers
Biographical sources
- Toby Harrah · SABR BioProject
- Toby Harrah · Retrosheet
- Boston Red Sox 9, Washington Senators 8 · Retrosheet box score
- Lahman Baseball Database – Society for American Baseball Research
- Cleveland Indians 16, Toronto Blue Jays 11 · Retrosheet box score
- Top Performances for Toby Harrah · Retrosheet game records
- The 1977 Texas Rangers · Retrosheet
Biography reviewed 2026-11-18. Suggest a correction with a source.